Parsha Toldot

November 18th 2023

5th of Kislev 5784

The Chosen One of the Avot

Rabbi David Chananya Pinto

“The lads grew up and Esav became one who knows hunting, a man of the field; but Yaakov was a wholesome man, abiding in tents” (Bereishit 25:27).

The above verse is how the Torah describes the beginning of the life of Yaakov Avinu, the chosen one of the Avot, who due to his greatness merited speaking with Hashem even when Yitzchak Avinu, his father, was still alive. He was considered as the chosen one of the Avot, for he was “a wholesome man, abiding in tents.” There are two explanations for his status: It is either owing to the power of Torah he had, or due to his unswerving integrity and honesty, the opposite of the middah of Esav and Lavan who were swindlers.

We will explain later that Yaakov Avinu took their trait of swindling and turned it into something positive by using it to overcome the evil inclination. We will clarify how he learned to use this trait for the good.

Yaakov Avinu knew that Lavan Ha’arami, the Aramean, was a swindler just as his name suggested. He was even worse than Esav, for Yaakov was already familiar with Esav’s wicked ways. Lavan, with his shrewdness, indeed managed to cheat Yaakov Avinu and gave him Leah in place of Rachel. Nevertheless, at the end of his stay in Lavan’s house, Yaakov Avinu says, “I have sojourned ) גרתי ( with Lavan” (Bereishit 32:5) and he was implying, “Though I have sojourned with Lavan, I have observed the 613 Divine Commandments ) )תריג and have not learned from his evil ways” (Rashi). He remained intact, spiritually.

From where did Yaakov Avinu draw this enormous power to fight against his evil inclination? He overcame his yetzer through using the power of deception. Meaning, he used the very strength of the enemy in order to overcome it. From here we learn the power of Torah that is learnt with great persistence. For 14 years Yaakov studied Torah, in exile, far from home, without letting his body rest. This power impacted him deep inside and gave him the strength to fight against all the ploys of the yetzer harah. But we still need to contemplate the matter; how Yaakov was able to implant deep and permanent foundations in his spirit, which enabled him to remain in close proximity to people who were experts in the craft of evil, yet not to be influenced by them.

Yaakov Avinu, who dedicated his whole life to learning Torah, felt the need to invest another fourteen years in yeshiva, on his way from Be’er Sheva to Charan, even though this delayed his fulfilling the commandment of his father to go and find a wife. Even though he was already sixty-three years old, he knew that only through learning Torah in the Yeshiva of Shem and Ever for fourteen years, will he be capable of overcoming the challenge waiting for him and to fight against and abolish the power of evil in Lavan.

According to this, we can understand what Chazal say “Rabbi Yishma’el says that if this villain (the yetzer hara) strikes you, pull him to the beit midrash (Kidushin 30b). This is the tactic to employ against the evil inclination and it is the only solution — learning our holy Torah. This is indeed what Yaakov Avinu did; before going to Lavan he stopped on the way and went to learn in the Yeshiva of Shem and Ever.

We see here a wonderful thing. After dedicating fourteen years to learning Torah in the Yeshiva of Shem and Ever, he departed for Charan and on the way experienced a revelation from Hashem. As the verse says “And behold! A ladder was set earthward and its top reached heavenward” (Bereishit 28:12). Due to his supreme efforts, he merited a revelation of the Shechina. Certainly, had he known this place was so holy he would not have slept there, as it says, “Yaakov awoke from his sleep and said, ‘Surely Hashem is present in this place and I did not know!’ And he became frightened and said, ‘How awesome is this place! This is none other than the abode of G-d and this is the gate of the heavens!’” (ibid. 16–17). But Hashem delayed him and made him fall asleep there so He could reveal Himself to him. All this Yaakov merited because he sacrificed his body and soul in order to diligently learn Torah.

From here we learn that Yaakov Avinu, with his wholehearted devotion to our holy Torah, dedicated every limb of his body for avodat Hashem; even his legs were committed to learning Torah and desired to sit and learn. This was the first time he went to sleep in those entire fourteen years, and even this was not by choice for Hashem brought the slumber upon him. And even in this sleep he dreamt about divrei Torah.

As it is written, “And Yaakov awoke from his sleep” (Bereishit 28:16) and Chazal say on this, “Don’t read it as ‘his sleep’ but ‘his learning’” (Bereishit Rabbah 69:7). How unlike our generation where people swallow tablets in order to gratify their body’s desire for a good sleep!

One of the Admorim of Alexander, zt”l, during the terrible Holocaust, was about to make Kiddush on Seder night. He began with words of encouragement to his chassidim and said, “Kadesh — a Jew must sanctify every limb in his body. This idea is very difficult and one achieves it only through Torah learning. As an example, when one washes ones hands one says the blessing, ‘Who has sanctified us with His commandments and has commanded us regarding washing the hands.’ One becomes holy through water, for Torah is compared to water.” These righteous people possessed a strength impossible to describe. They faced their terribly cruel deaths while singing songs of praise to their Creator. This power came from their total sanctification and supreme dedication to their Creator.

This foundation is what Yaakov Avinu implanted in all of us. A person must constantly stay connected to Hashem, and if he feels a weakening in his spirituality, the way to overcome it is only through learning Torah.


Based on the teachings of Moreinu v‘Rabbeinu Hagaon Hatzaddik Rabbi David Chananya Pinto, shlita

The Tent of Yaakov Versus the Field of Esav

“The lads grew up and Esav became one who knows hunting, a man of the field; but Yaakov was a wholesome man, abiding in tents” (Bereishit 25:27).

Yaakov and Esav — two brothers, two lifestyles. Esav was known as a man of the “field,” while Yaakov was a man of “tents.” A tent is generally pitched in a field with the help of pegs so it should remain steady, so that even a sudden strong wind will not blow it over. The size of the pegs must be in proportion to the size of the tent — a large tent needs large, strong pegs so it should not collapse no matter the weather conditions.

Yaakov sat in “tents” and Esav was a man of the “field.” This alludes to the fact that Yaakov, in order not to be influenced by the ‘”work of the field,” referring to the concept of materialism, had to pitch his tent firmly with strong pegs. This tent refers to the tent of Torah. And there inside the tent he sacrificed everything for Torah, so he shouldn’t be influenced by Esav the rasha, a man of the field.

This is a lesson for all generations. If a person wishes to be saved and protected from the “field,” from the trivialities and superficialities of this world, he must pitch his tent firmly.

Yaakov Avinu pitched his tent in the field, where he was secluded and separated from the rest of the world. Inside the tent he could grow spiritually and devote his entire being to Torah. In the merit of the Torah Yaakov learned, he was able to inspire all his surroundings with the spirit of Torah, all from inside the tent.

Therefore, when Yaakov left Be’er Sheva the people sensed that a tzaddik had left and they felt the lack of blessing which they merited from having Yaakov’s presence among them. Chazal say, “A righteous person’s departure from a place leaves a void. As long as he lives in a city, he constitutes its glory, its splendor, and its beauty; when he departs, its glory, splendor, and beauty depart with him.” Yaakov Avinu, by secluding himself in the tent and toiling in Torah, was the glory, splendor and beauty of the place. In his merit the entire town was blessed.

When Yaakov Avinu left, they all felt the loss of his presence. This was because he firmly planted his tent in the field, submerging himself in Torah study and secluding himself from all materialism. Through this he transformed the area into a spiritual place.


Tidbits of faith and trust penned by Moreinu v‘Rabbeinu Hagaon Hatzaddik Rabbi David Chananya Pinto, shlita

Four for Faith

How happy was the man who informed me that he and his wife were blessed to be expecting a child. But their blessing was not ordinary in the least. It was quadrupled, for his wife was expecting four babies!

“After some testing,” he confided, his voice lowered and lacking some of its former enthusiasm, “the doctors are afraid that not all of the babies will make it. They suggest aborting two of the four, so the other two will have a chance to be born healthy.”

He asked my opinion. Obviously, each case must be dealt with individually, and one cannot take an example from any situation for his own issue. My advice to this man was that he should check into the halachic aspect of the matter. My opinion was that he should not abort at all. Rather, he should strengthen his faith in Hashem. Just as Hashem had placed four neshamot into his wife’s body, He would see to it that they would live and be born healthy.

The man acquiesced, refusing to obey the doctors.

With the progression of the pregnancy, the doctors again tried to persuade the couple to abort two of the fetuses. The man came to me once again, asking for my advice. I told him, “Where there is faith and trust in Hashem, there is no room for danger! Hashem gives a woman the ability to carry children and give birth to healthy babies. He alone holds the key to life. Have trust in Him and do not be discouraged by the doctors’ words.”

This man was not an observant Jew, but he had firm faith in Hashem. He withstood the test and refused to abort.

This was not an easy challenge. The doctors warned him that at any given moment, his wife was likely to lose all four babies. But his steadfast faith stood by him and gave him the strength to cope with this challenge. In the merit of his faith, he received four beautiful, bouncing babies. This reinforced his faith in Hashem even further. He made a complete turnaround and is now an observant Jew.

How great is the power of faith to bring blessing and miracle upon the one who trusts in Hashem.


The Way the Shadchan Extols the Father

“And may G-d give you of the dew of the heavens and of the fatness of the earth” (Bereishit 27:28).

In the middle of Parshat Toldot we read about the blessings Yitzchak Avinu blessed his sons, first Yaakov Avinu and then Esav. If we delve into the content of the blessings we will find something that needs clarifying.

In the blessings showered on Yaakov, his father starts to bless him with something heavenly, “And may G-d give you of the dew of the heavens” and only afterwards with something worldly, “and of the fatness of the earth.”

However, when Yitzchak blessed Esav, he started with the worldly blessing, “of the fatness of the earth shall be your dwelling” and finished with the heavenly blessing, “and of the dew of the heavens of above” (ibid. 39).

What lies behind this difference in the way they were blessed?

The sefer Sha’ar Bat Rabim brings a beautiful explanation on this, using the following parable:

When a shadchan suggests a shidduch for a boy, if the bachur is a true ben-Torah, diligent and dedicated to Torah learning, then the shadchan starts by praising the father of the girl in this way: He describes how the father is someone who loves and appreciates Torah, has great yirat Shamayim and all his aspirations are for Torah and yirat Shamayim, he even has his own beit midrash full of sefarim where the bachur will be able to sit and delve into Torah day and night. At the end of the conversation he mentions, by the way, that the father also has the means to provide for his daughter since he owns great wealth.

On the other hand, if the bachur is not a ben-Torah and worldly things are more important to him than learning Torah, the shadchan will change around his words. Right at the start he brings up the father’s financial means, describing how he owns a playing field and a gym and of his intention to provide generously for the couple. Afterwards he mentions that he also has a large library with many Torah texts and if the bachur so wishes, he can sit there and study.

The shadchan speaks to each one according to his spiritual level.

This is indeed what occurred with Yitzchak Avinu. Divine Inspiration spoke from this throat, therefore when it came to Yaakov who was “a wholesome man, abiding in tents,” who spent his days in Torah and avodah, Hashem guided Yitzchak to bless him first with heavenly things and only afterwards with “fatness of the earth” — for “If there is no flour there is no Torah.”

On the other hand, when it came to Esav who followed his desires and loved worldly pleasures, Hashem guided Yitzchak to start the blessing with worldly gifts, and as Rashi explains he gave him “Italy of Greece (Rome),” for there he would be able to enjoy the pleasures of this world. Secondly, if he wishes, he can also enjoy something spiritual “of the dew of the heavens of above.”


Saved by the Caftan

Once, when Rabbi Aminadav Krispin, Rav of Kiryat Bialik, rode on a bus from Haifa to Tel Aviv, a senior police force officer sat beside him. In the course of their conversation, they discovered they both originated from Mogador.

Inevitably, Rabbi Krispin asked the police officer, “Did you know Rabbi Chaim Pinto Hakatan?”

“Of course!” answered the officer. “Who did not know him?” He continued to surprise Rabbi Krispin, saying, “I am alive only in his merit.” He began to relate his incredible story.

When he was young, he decided to work as a truck driver for a French transportation company, running a route from Morocco to Mauritania. Since at that time there was a war raging between the French and the Moslem rebels, his mother advised him to get a blessing from Rabbi Chaim Pinto before investing in a truck.

Rabbi Chaim Hakatan blessed the young man with a safe journey, and added that he advised his mother to buy him a white caftan, which he should keep next to the driver’s seat.

The suggestion did not find favor in the eyes of the young fellow. “Honorable Rabbi, in our days, only the Arabs wear caftans. The modern European style has already replaced the caftans. Why should I buy one?!”

The Rav just repeated his advice, “Do as I say. The time will come when the caftan will save your life.” He did not elaborate any further.

The young man relented to the Rav’s request. The caftan was bought for him as the tzaddik suggested and placed near the driver’s seat. The words of the tzaddik rang in his ears, “The time will come when the caftan will save your life.”

Four months passed since he had begun his new job working for the transportation company. One night, he parked in a place where drivers found shelter from the rebels. Due to the cold night, he put on the caftan his mother had bought him on the advice of Rabbi Chaim Pinto, and fell asleep.

At sunrise, the driver awoke from his deep sleep refreshed and full of energy, ready to continue on his route. However, when he looked out of the window, he was horrified at the sight that met his eyes. The decapitated heads of the drivers were hanging from the trucks that had stopped at the stopover…

Later, he realized that on that very night, the rebels had struck the parking area. They had methodically passed from truck to truck, inspecting the sleeping drivers, and concluded that anyone dressed in European attire was French, promptly cutting off his head. However, the drivers dressed in traditional white caftans were not harmed, since the rebels figured these were Moroccan Arabs.

“This is how I was saved in the merit of the tzaddik’s blessings and advice,” the officer explained.

When the driver returned home, he told his mother what had occurred and then hurried to Rabbi Chaim’s house to thank him and recite the Birkat Hagomel, thanking

Hashem for saving him from death. That same week he packed up all his belongings and left the country to live Eretz Yisrael.


“Yitzchak loved Esav for game was in his mouth” (Bereishit 25:28).

This verse gives rise to a difficulty. How can one say about Yitzchak, that he loved his son for game was in his mouth? Yitzchak loved him because Esav gave him tasty food??

A Talmid Chacham brought this question before the Maharil Diskin, who answered in this way:

Yitzchak Avinu did not love Esav because of what he hunted, because of the food he brought him, rather he loved him because he was his firstborn son. Where do we see this love? From the fact that “game was in his mouth” — from the fact that Yitzchak ate from his shechita. Had Yitzchak considered Esav a rasha, he would not have eaten from his shechita and would have hated him. This shows us that Yitzchak considered Esav a tzaddik, therefore he loved him.

The words “for game was in his mouth” is not the reason for Yitzchak’s love, rather it is the proof of his love.

The Maharil Diskin adds that as we know, Hashem prevents tzaddikim from making mistakes, especially when it comes to food. Yitzchak did not transgress the prohibition of eating forbidden food by relying on Esav’s shechita. Rivkah, who understood who Esav really was, made sure there was always someone supervising Esav’s shechita.

The Torah’s Protection

“May the days of mourning for my father draw near, then I will kill my brother Yaakov” (Bereishit 27:41).

The Kli Yakar writes that Esav wished his father would die, for a mourner is prohibited from learning Torah, and so Yaakov would not have the merit of the Torah’s protection.

The sefer Derech Sichah brings a question that was asked to Rabbi Chaim Kanievsky, zt”l. A mourner is permitted to learn certain aspects of Torah, so it seems he does have the merit of the Torah’s protection?

Rabbi Chaim answered that a mourner is indeed forbidden to learn Torah. The sections permitted are allowed only because they are applicable to his situation. This is compared to the Torah learning of women, who learn only in order to know how to observe the mitzvot. They do not learn for the sake of learning itself, and this is not enough of a merit to earn the Torah’s protection.

A Person Becomes his Clothing

“Rivkah then took her older son Esav’s clean garments which were with her in the house, and clothed Yaakov her young son” (Bereishit 27:15).

The holy Rabbi Naftoli of Ropshitz, zt”l, says, “Take a look at the influence the clothes have on a person!” He explains: Not for nothing did Rivkah dress Yaakov with the precious garments of Esav. It was extremely hard for Yaakov to stand before his father the tzaddik and tell a lie, for his entire being was bound up with the truth, just as it says “Grant truth to Yaakov.” If so, how would he merit to receive the blessings Rivkah was determined he should receive?

Therefore, his mother acted with ingenuity and dressed him in the clothes of Esav. When a person dresses like Esav, he automatically becomes a bit like him…


Sand or Stars?

“I will increase your offspring like the stars of the heaven” (Bereishit 26:4).

In several places in Tanach, Am Yisrael are compared to the stars of the heavens and to the sand of the seashore.

The Gemarah tells us (Megillah 16a) that when Am Yisrael reach great heights, they are compared to the stars, and when they fall, chalilah, they are compared to dust and sand. The stars in heaven seem to be spread out, each one a light on its own, with thousands of kilometers separating between them.

Grains of sand, however, seem to be stuck to one another, as if united. But in fact, the opposite is true. Rabbi Yisrael of Tchorkatov, zt”l, says, that in actual fact the stars are grouped in many sets, all surrounding the largest and brightest star, as in the arrangement of the sun. On the other hand, concerning the sand, each grain stands on its own; any slight wind will blow it from its place…

So it is with Am Yisrael. When they are “down,” at a low level, they are compared to the sand. In the absence of achdut (unity), any slight wind blows them apart. But when they are united, which means they are all focused on the Torah and it is the Torah that holds them together, then they are on a high level and are compared to the stars.


Hevrat Pinto • 32, rue du Plateau 75019 Paris - FRANCE • Tél. : +331 42 08 25 40 • Fax : +331 42 06 00 33 • © 2015 • Webmaster : Hanania Soussan